Topics: Finance & Accounting Outsourcing, Senior Living

The Holiday Pay Question Your Board Hasn’t Been Asked Yet 

Posted on November 17, 2026
Written By Nishant Kumar

The Holiday Pay Question Your Board Hasn't Been Asked Yet 
Summarize and analyze this article with:

On 19 March 2026, the government published a list of 389 employers. All of them were named for underpaying the minimum wage. Social care was one of the sectors on it. 

No board wants its name on a list like that. And for most senior living operators, minimum wage is well under control. Holiday pay is a different story. 

From 2027, the Fair Work Agency is expected to start enforcing holiday pay. The government has also asked whether employers who underpay it should be named, in the same way. The proposed penalty? Up to 200% of the amount owed, capped at £20,000 per worker. 

This is the bit that’s easy to miss. The proposed look-back period reaches back to 18 December 2025. That date has already passed. So the period an inspector could one day examine has already started! 

That changes the conversation. Carers who regularly pick up extra shifts may be owed more in holiday pay than they’re getting. If that’s happening, the shortfall is building up now, week by week. And since April 2026, you’ve been legally required to keep the records that would show it. 

How confident are you in what those records say? 

Below, we look at how the risk has shifted and what a lesson from Australia shows. We also share five questions worth putting to your finance director this week. 

The risk that used to sleep 

For years, holiday pay errors had a quiet safety net. Someone had to notice them first. 

A carer would need to spot the mistake, work out the sums and bring a claim. Most never did. So the risk sat on the books, unseen and untested. 

That safety net is about to go. 

 Until now From 2027 (expected) 
Who finds the error? The worker, if they ever spot it The Fair Work Agency, after a complaint or on its own initiative 
How it’s settled One tribunal claim at a time Notices of Underpayment, much as with minimum wage enforcement 
What it costs The arrears owed to that worker Arrears plus a proposed penalty of 200%, capped at £20,000 per worker 
Public naming Not used for holiday pay Under consultation 
Your evidence Rarely tested Records required since 6 April 2026, kept for six years 

Look at that last row again. The records are the evidence. If they’re thin, the agency won’t simply give you the benefit of the doubt. 

There’s one more detail most coverage misses. Under the proposals, employers who repay arrears before an investigation starts avoid a penalty. 

So the timing matters. Finding the gap yourself costs the arrears. Being found costs more. Which would your board rather explain? 

The new rule most operators missed 

Here’s a change that slipped in quietly. Many finance teams still haven’t caught up with it. 

  1. It’s already law. Since 6 April 2026, every employer has had to keep records of annual leave and holiday pay. This isn’t a 2027 change. It’s in force now. 
  2. The records have to last six years. That’s six years of leave taken, leave carried over and holiday pay. It includes how each figure was made up, overtime and all. 
  3. Hardly anyone announced it. The government barely flagged it. The payroll body CIPP warned that many employers may not even know about it. 
  4. There’s no template. Nobody has said what “adequate” records look like. Each employer has to make its own judgement call. A legal duty with no template. Lovely! 
  5. Getting it wrong could be a criminal matter. Failing to keep adequate holiday records is now a criminal offence, not just an admin slip. 

For most care operators, the data does exist somewhere. It’s spread across rotas, timesheets, payroll exports and the odd spreadsheet. The real question is whether anyone can pull it together quickly when an inspector asks.  

What happens when the records aren’t there? 

This is the part boards rarely ask about until it’s too late. So let’s ask it now. 

  1. Will inspectors give us notice before they visit? No, they don’t have to. Inspectors can turn up unannounced. That means your records need to be ready on any given day, not just ahead of audit week. 
  2. What if our records are patchy? Then the agency fills the gaps itself. It can make its own estimate of what you owe. And it’s unlikely to estimate in your favour. 
  3. Is it only ever one carer’s pay that’s wrong? Rarely. Holiday pay errors tend to come from the same rule applied to everyone. If overtime is missing for one carer, it’s probably missing for the whole rota. One complaint can quickly turn into a review of the whole workforce. 
  4. Does the agency replace the tribunal route? No. Staff can still bring their own claims. From 1 October 2026, they also have six months to do it instead of three. So there are now two ways for an error to come to light. 

Put simply, without records you can’t prove you paid people correctly. Patchy records leave someone else to decide what you owe. 

Australia ran this experiment first 

Want a preview of state enforcement in a care workforce? Look at Australia. Its Fair Work Ombudsman has been checking aged care payrolls for years. 

Case study: Southern Cross Care (NSW & ACT) 

  • Who: A not-for-profit aged care, home care and retirement living provider. It runs 27 retirement communities and 27 care homes. 
  • The trigger: One employee asked about their overtime pay. That question led to a self-audit in 2023. 
  • What it found: Overtime, weekend penalties, shift loadings and annual leave loading had all been underpaid. The errors went back to July 2017. 
  • The cause: Problems with its time and attendance system, plus a manual payroll process. 
  • The bill: More than $11.7 million, owed to 5,500 staff. 

One question. Seven years of pay data. Thousands of staff. 

And Southern Cross Care isn’t an outlier. In August 2026, the regulator reported on 22 aged care businesses it had investigated. Thirteen weren’t fully compliant. Two were also fined for record-keeping and payslip breaches. 

What should a UK board take from this? This isn’t an Australian problem. The pattern appears wherever a care rota, overtime and manual payroll meet. The only difference was who started looking. 

The UK is now building the same machinery. The best time to run your own audit is before someone asks. 

The wellbeing trap inside rolled-up pay 

Rolled-up holiday pay can look like a neat fix. For irregular-hours and bank staff, holiday pay is added to every payslip. Nothing builds up, and there’s no balance to track. 

It’s lawful, and payroll teams like it. But in a care setting, the neatest option can still bring problems of its own. 

Looks efficient Hidden cost 
Holiday pay is settled each pay period Staff may treat it as normal wages and forget it’s meant for time off 
No leave balances to track for bank staff Acas itself warns it might put some workers off taking holidays 
Fewer calculations when someone takes leave Fewer breaks for staff already doing long shifts and extra cover 
A tidy payroll process The strain shows up on the rota, not on the payslip 

So who’s actually resting? In care, tiredness isn’t only an HR issue. It affects cover, sickness absence and, in the end, residents. 

None of this means rolled-up pay is wrong. It means the decision belongs with operations, not just payroll. Does anyone check whether rolled-up staff actually take time off? 

It’s a question worth asking at board level. Nobody else is likely to ask it. 

Five questions to put to your finance director this week 

You don’t need a full audit to know where you stand. Five straight answers will tell you a lot. 

  1. Do we include regular overtime in holiday pay? If carers often pick up extra shifts, that overtime may need to be included in their holiday pay. If the answer is “basic hours only”, that’s your first warning sign. 
  2. Can we show how each holiday pay figure was worked out? Not just the total, but how it was built up. If the answer starts with “it’s in a spreadsheet somewhere”, keep asking. 
  3. Could we produce six years of records by Friday? Inspectors don’t have to give notice. A good answer here is “yes, from one place”. Anything slower is worth looking into. 
  4. Do we know which staff count as irregular-hours workers? Their holiday rules are different. Bank and zero-hours staff are easy to get wrong. Is the list current, and who keeps it up to date? 
  5. Who actually owns this: HR, payroll or finance? If everyone owns it, nobody really does. One name should be accountable. 

If two or more answers make you pause, look now. Under the proposals, putting things right before an investigation starts could avoid a penalty. Waiting is the expensive option. 

How QX Global Group Helps?

At QX Global Group, we work with senior living operators across the UK to take the pressure off their finance function. Our teams bring sector experience to day-to-day finance and accounting work. We pair it with standard workflows and automation that cut out manual errors. The result is cleaner numbers, clearer reporting and records you can rely on when someone asks to see them. 

If holiday pay has become one more thing your team is juggling, we’d be happy to talk it through. There’s no pressure. Just a straightforward conversation about where you stand and what might help. 

What’s the Bottom Line? 

For most operators, holiday pay has never been a boardroom topic. It sat with payroll and rarely caused any trouble. 

That’s changing. The records duty is already in force. State enforcement is expected from 2027. And the period an inspector could one day look at has already begun. 

None of this calls for panic. It calls for a quiet look under the bonnet. Is regular overtime in the numbers? Can you show how each figure was reached? Does one person own the process? 

Operators who check now get to fix things on their own terms. Those who wait may end up fixing them under someone else’s. 

The records are due either way. Better they’re ready. 

FAQs 

When did the holiday pay record-keeping rule start?  

It started on 6 April 2026. Since then, every UK employer has had to keep records of annual leave and holiday pay. 

How long do we need to keep holiday records?  

For at least six years from the date they were made. 

Should regular overtime count towards holiday pay?  

Yes, if it’s worked regularly and forms part of normal earnings. That’s very common for carers who pick up extra shifts. 

When will the Fair Work Agency start enforcing holiday pay?  

From 2027. Until then, workers can still bring their own claims through an employment tribunal. 

What penalties could apply for underpaying holiday pay?  

The proposed penalty is 200% of the amount owed, capped at £20,000 per worker. This is still a proposal, not final. 

How long do staff have to bring a holiday pay claim?  

Six months, up from three months. 

Education:

  • B.Com
  • MBA (Marketing)

Nishant Kumar

Vice President - Sales (UK & Europe)

Nishant Kumar is a senior commercial leader with 20+ years of experience supporting hospitality and accommodation businesses through technology-enabled outsourcing and operational transformation. At QX Global Group, he works with property owners, asset managers, and hospitality leaders across the UK and Europe to improve profitability, modernise back-office operations, and build scalable operating models. His expertise spans finance and accounting, payroll, and digital enablement for multi-property and franchise-led hospitality organisations, with a strong focus on cost optimisation, standardisation, and automation-led efficiencies.

Expertise: Hospitality and accommodation outsourcing, Multi-entity finance transformation, Shared services and global delivery models, Automation-led cost optimisation, Strategic commercial advisory

Don't forget to share this post!

Originally published Nov 17, 2026 01:11:39, updated Nov 18 2026

Topics: Finance & Accounting Outsourcing, Senior Living


Related Topics

Living Sector Finance Models: What UK CFOs Need to Know

Living Sectors Are Converging. Their Fin...

12 Nov 2026

Living platforms increasingly span more than one product. A group may operate BTR homes, student acc...

Read More
Property Management Accounting Services

Property Management Accounting Services:...

12 Nov 2026

Repairs data usually begins life as an operational record: a leak, a failed pump, a broken entry sys...

Read More
BTR Accounting Services

BTR Accounting Services: Keeping Portfol...

10 Nov 2026

BTR, PBSA and co-living may now sit in the same investment platform, but their finance definitions h...

Read More
Why Property Accounting Teams Still Can't Close Before Day 10 and How to Fix It

Why Property Accounting Teams Still Can&...

09 Nov 2026

For a lot of property accounting teams, the close still runs well into the second week of the month....

Read More